Dreams
The Songs He Only Sings Alone
Avinash used to write down every new song, one line at a time. Then people laughed at his voice so much that today he only hums when he is alone. A true story, and a question: does the right to sing belong only to people with good voices?
Real story, names changed
When someone does something for the first time in front of another person, that person's reaction decides, to a great extent, whether they will do it again, and whether they will do it with confidence. The listener rarely knows how much responsibility rests on him, and often, without meaning to, he becomes the reason someone's passion dies.
Today's story is a true one, and it is about exactly this: how a fear of something settles into a person, one that he has to face every single day.
It is the story of Avinash, who lives in a city in Uttar Pradesh.
One Page, One Song
Avinash was a bright child from the start. For his first five years, he studied in a Hindi-medium school. After he sat his Class 3 exams, the school turned English-medium, and he had to be admitted to Class 3 all over again.
He loved listening to songs and humming them. But he never sang in front of anyone.
As soon as a new song came out, he would copy it onto a sheet of paper. It wasn't as easy as it sounds. He would play the song, stop it in the middle, write down a line, then play on. Then he would memorise that line. This went on until he knew the whole song by heart.
This was the time of keypad phones. You had to recharge your data first, and only then could you use it. Once, a friend asked him for the lyrics of a song. He came home from school, changed his clothes, ate, and set to work. He loved songs by Arijit Singh and Honey Singh most of all. The moment anyone mentioned a song, he would drop everything else and get to it.
"Be Quiet"
Sometimes, when he hummed in front of his family, the answer would come: "Be quiet, you sound like a cow bellowing." He felt they were making fun of him. When he sang in front of his friends, they said nothing.
A Day in Class Eight
When he was in Class 8, there was a Hindi teacher at his school whom he respected a great deal. One day, the teacher had to leave the school. On his farewell day, he said to Avinash, "Sing something. I'll record it and take it with me."
He sang Honey Singh's raps. He was very happy that day. It may have been the first time anyone had told him to sing.
The Changed Voice
But as he grew older, his voice kept changing, and he began to feel that it was no longer what it used to be. A little later, he tried once more to sing in front of other people. They laughed. Someone said, "Shut up, my ears will burst."
After that, he never tried again.
Today
Even now, he listens to songs. But he doesn't sing in front of anyone. He only writes them out when he is alone, and hums them.
A Question
Sometimes we plant such a fear in someone's mind that either they can never get out of it, or it takes them a very long time to. And sometimes the fear never leaves.
If we go to the heart of this, one question comes up: does the right to sing belong only to people with good voices? If someone's voice isn't good but they love singing, can't we encourage them too? How can we take away someone's right to sing just because their voice isn't good?
And the bigger question: should the right to do anything belong only to the people who already do it very well? For some people, the answer will be yes. But if they were put in the place of those it happens to, perhaps they would change their answer.
To sing a song, you must know the song. To paint a picture, you must have its image in your mind. To cook, you must know what you're making and have the ingredients. To dance, you must love the art. If these things are inside a person, they will learn by making mistakes. But if you kill their heart itself by telling them "you are not made for this, give it up", how will they ever learn? From what someone does today, we cannot say for certain that they could never be excellent at it later. What they need is to be told how to improve their weakness, not to have the pleasure taken from them.
A human being is far above measures like good and bad, foolish and wise. Understand this, see everyone as whole, and keep yourself and others happy.
The next time someone sings in front of us for the first time, what will our first reaction be?
Read another story
Seventeen Out of a Hundred
Real story, names changed
Teachers are called a form of God. But what happens when a teacher with the power to give marks uses that same power to frighten a girl, and the school protects him by calling him its best teacher? A true incident, with names changed. Content note: This story mentions a teacher's harassment of a child.
हिंदी में पढ़ें →Your story belongs here too
There may be someone who needs to know they are not alone.
Share an experience in your own words. You can choose to remain anonymous.
Tell your storyStay with the stories
A new story in your inbox.
Get a new story in your inbox every Tuesday, Thursday and Saturday.
If this stayed with you
Share this story:
Send a private note to the author
Your note is private and will not appear publicly.