What No One Asks
We Have Given You Complete Freedom
A conversation begins with “You’re not going.” Later, the same voice says, “We have given you complete freedom.” One small scene, and one question: is freedom something that can be given?
Real story, names changed
You may have heard this conversation before.
A boy is telling his mother, over the phone, that a friend of his is getting married and has invited him. The answer comes without a moment's pause: "You're not going."
He doesn't argue. He says, "Okay," and puts the phone in his pocket. There is no anger on his face. Only the tiredness that comes from saying "okay" too many times.
A few days later, in that same house, someone is telling the guests, "We have given our children complete freedom. When did we ever stop them from anything?"
And somewhere else, another voice, often said with pride: "My partner doesn't go anywhere without asking me. Doesn't talk to anyone. I even have the password to their Instagram."
For these voices, "not stopping" is itself a great achievement. Those who stop at that will hardly think of inspiring someone to move forward.
Freedom is not something you can give. It is every person's own right. If someone doesn't have it, that is the real sorrow, not whether somebody "gave" it or didn't.
Where to go, what to eat, whom to marry, what time to be back home: many people grow up in homes where all of these decisions are imposed on them. We can accept that those who love want to keep the other person safe. But the difference between keeping someone safe and keeping them tied down is very small.
A person plays many roles from birth until death: brother or sister, friend, son or daughter, husband or wife, mother or father. But a person is not only the role they are playing. They are far more than that. Everyone gets only one life; even if there is a next birth, who remembers it? Playing so many roles is a big and lovely thing. But if, in exchange, someone is never given the chance to live their own life, how can that be right?
Both can exist together, if the two people understand each other properly.
We don't know whether that boy ever raised the wedding again. We only know that he had become very good at saying "okay."
Read another observation
Real story, names changed
Is a Girl's Life Really Easier?
Some people believe girls have an easier life than boys. But when we compare, we only see what looks easy and forget our own opportunities. This essay is about the burdens we never count.
Read observation →
Real story, names changed
The Ravan Wasn't Only in the Effigy
Two friends go to their first Ravan Dahan and see something in the crowd they still can't shake. The effigy burns once a year. The question is where the real Ravan is standing.
Read observation →
Fictional / composite
She Asked for the Free Coriander First
At a vegetable cart one evening, a woman asked for the free coriander before she had bought anything. A nine-year-old watched her put the tomatoes back. Nobody said a word about it.
Read observation →
Your story belongs here too
There may be someone who needs to know they are not alone.
Share an experience in your own words. You can choose to remain anonymous.
Tell your storyStay with the stories
A new story in your inbox.
Get a new story in your inbox every Tuesday, Thursday and Saturday.
If this stayed with you
Share this story:
Send a private note to the author
Your note is private and will not appear publicly.